American Idol Top 24

Well, it's American Idol time again and it's time for our yearly contest..."Who Can Predict The Top Twelve?" Please keep in mind that this is not who we personally like, but who we think America likes based on the first week's performances.  We're putting our predictions out in the internet universe so that there will be no question of either our brilliance or stupidity, depending on how it all turns out.

So here goes! Here are the contestants on both of our lists:
Crystal Bowersox

Tim Urban

Lacey Brown

Casey James

Michael Lynche

 

Haeley Vaughn

 

Lee Dewyze

 

Andrew Garcia

 

 Didi Benami

 

 Here's where we diverge...

Daniela's Picks

Janell Wheeler

Todrick Hall

 

 Michelle Delamor

 

Celina's Picks

Lilly Scott

Katie Stevens

 

 Joe Munoz

 

Post Idol Comments:

Daniela--I lost one this week with Janell Wheeler.  I'm a little sad...oh well...at least all my boys are still in it. 

Final Score after first elimination: 11 out of 12 still on my list. 

Celina is more sad than I am because Joe Munoz went home this week.  He was on her list not because she thought he could win, but because she loved him. I'm sorry, Celina! 

Final Score after first elimination: 11 out of 12 still on Celina's list.